We’ve reached the neutral site portion of the tournament, which means we have an exciting Friday night of regional semifinal action. With 20 Central Ohio teams still in playoffs mode, we take a look at some of the top matchups we’ll be following tonight.
Division I, Region 3
#5 Upper Arlington (10-2) vs. #1 Olentangy Liberty (10-2)
Upper Arlington
Second Round: #4 Olentangy Orange 24-20
Olentangy Liberty
Second Round: #8 Groveport Madison 27-7
Fantastic 50 prediction: Olentangy Liberty -11
Upper Arlington knows everything about tonight’s game very well. This will be their fourth playoff game at Westerville Central’s Warhawk Stadium since 2020. They’re only 1-2 in those games, but the only win was a regional championship in 2021. The Golden Bears have returned to the semifinal in every year since, and only fell a few plays short of winning another regional title since. No one in Central Ohio has been on a better run this decade than the Golden Bears. Last week their defense once again terrorized a quality opponent, sending them into the winter sports season. And now, for the second year in a row, they face the number one seed in Region 3, a league opponent who they’ve played every year since the 2020 season.
Upper Arlington struggled to find answers against the Olentangy Liberty offense, led by Central District Offensive Player of the Year, Andrew Leonard. The Patriots jumped out to a 28-16 fourth quarter lead against Upper Arlington last month. They’ve lead every opponent by at least two scores at one point this season. They have arguably the best quarterback-receiver connection in Central Ohio with Leonard and breakout senior Christian Moulton. In two instances however, those leads weren’t enough and Olentangy Liberty’s offense wasn’t able to expand before a furious comeback was routed. In a game like this, the small wins mean everything. Winning the field position, time of possession, and turnover battles will be the difference as Upper Arlington looks to recapture the fourth quarter magic from their 15-0 run just a few weeks ago.
#7 Pickerington North (10-2) vs. #6 Olentangy Berlin (10-2)
Pickerington North
Second Round: #2 Pickerington Central 35-14
Olentangy Berlin
Second Round: #3 Gahanna Lincoln 17-14
Fantastic 50 prediction: Pickerington North -11
In many cases, celebrating a win with your students in the bleachers at your rivals’ new stadium twice in the same season, with the second occurrence ending their season in the playoffs is more than enough for a successful season. Pickerington North isn’t satisfied with their third consecutive win over Pickerington Central, and they certainly have bigger goals than returning to the regional semifinal. After a sobering loss at home to Gahanna Lincoln, the Panthers have dominated in their first two playoff wins, and now it’s time to right the wrong of last season, when they struggled to find anything offensively in a semifinal loss to Hilliard Bradley. Pickerington North is the lowest remaining seed in Region 3, but as offensive lineman Ayden Annarino told us on the sideline, don’t be fooled by the number 7 that sits next to Pickerington North’s name. Pickerington North’s riches of talent was on display when Preston Bowman took over the game. His coffin-corner punt led to a strip sack touchdown. Then he took two plays to the house—one one a short pass and another on a direct snap to put the game away. In the first matchup against Pickerington Central, it was Michael Taylor, whose record-setting all-purpose performance blew the game open in the second half.
Olentangy Berlin held on tight for a very on-brand 17-14 win over Gahanna Lincoln on the road. While Gahanna Lincoln ended the season shorthanded after Brennen Ward’s hand injury, the difficulty of beating Gahanna Lincoln in their place doesn’t change. Olentangy Berlin has already seen some of the best of what Central Ohio has to offer with wins over Olentangy and Olentangy Liberty. They also went on the road to see Olentangy Orange and Upper Arlington this season. Led by Aiden Eviston on offense, Olentangy Berlin will capitalize on opportunities whenever they see them, but the number one priority will be to limit the amount of time Pickerington North’s offense sees the field.
Division I, Region 2
#8 Wayne (7-5) vs. #5 Hilliard Davidson (8-4)
Hilliard Davidson
Second Round: #13 Hilliard Bradley 34-12
Wayne
Second Round: #1 Kettering Fairmont 20-10
Fantastic 50 prediction: Hilliard Davidson -9
After two rematches from the regular season, Hilliard Davidson shifts their attention to a new opponent for the first time this postseason. The Wildcats will face Wayne for a trip to the regional championship. This is Davidson’s deepest postseason run since 2018. They defeated this same program 28-21 in the first round back then. Today, they are led by quarterback Johnny DiBlasio and his favorite target Kaden Windham, a punishing running back in Keevin Gibbon, who runs behind a forceful offensive line, and a deep group of linebackers and safeties that include Hayden Buckley and Paul Knapke. Hilliard Davidson’s depth of returning starters has been a strength all season. It’s been awhile since they got here, but Hilliard Davidson has always prided themselves on building a program designed to win on the third Friday of November, and beyond.
Wayne is one of two GWOC teams who will face an OCC-Central opponent in Region 2 tonight. If not for early-season injuries, the Warriors would have likely fared much better than a 5-5 regular season. Wayne flashes some of the best talent out of the Dayton area with quarterback Tyrell Lewis and receivers Jamier Averette-Brown, Teaunn Hunter, and Gauge Miesse. The trio combined for nine receptions, 133 yards, and a touchdown. A shorthanded Fairmont team out gained Wayne by 90 yards in the ground game, but two interceptions and two long touchdown runs of 34 and 55 yards were enough for Wayne to end the number one seed’s season last week.
#14 Dublin Coffman (4-8) vs. #2 Centerville (9-3)
Dublin Coffman
Second Round: #6 Lebanon 56-20
Centerville
Second Round: #7 Springboro 14-7
Fantastic 50 prediction: Centerville -14
Quarterback Amari Valerio-Hudson has turned a great regular season into a stunning postseason. It would be unfair to the rest of the Dublin Coffman team to say he’s gotten them to this point by himself, but with 14 total touchdowns in the first two rounds, he’s certainly carrying more than just the weight of his shoulder pads this November. The Shamrocks’ 105 points in wins over Lebanon and Westland are the most among Central Ohio teams still playing for the regional title. The question heading into the Region 2 semifinal tonight is whether or not Valerio-Hudson can break out against what many believe to be the best defensive unit remaining in this bracket.
Centerville has only allowed 17 points per game in 12 contests. This includes a rough stretch to start the year, where they gave up 127 points in their first four games of the season. The Elks have a dangerous dual threat quarterback of their own in junior Shane Cole, and their linebacker group will be the key in trying to silence Valerio-Hudson. Centerville’s defense has been much improved since early in the year, and with a recent home-and-home series in 2022-23, there’s a lot familiarity between these programs. But this is Centerville’s first time preparing for Valerio-Hudson under his new role in the offense.
Division II, Region 7
#4 Ashland (7-5) vs. #1 Big Walnut (11-1)
Big Walnut
Second Round: #9 Massillon Perry 35-24
Ashland
Second Round: #5 Columbus St. Francis DeSales 27-14
Fantastic 50 prediction: Big Walnut -2
The beast that is Massillon Washington likely awaits the winner of this game, but it’s still one of the best regional semifinal matchups across all of Division II tonight. The Ashland Arrows and Big Walnut Eagles have both risen from the mats after 5-win regular seasons to combine for 23-1 records this season. Big Walnut’s underclassman talent already had us excited for the future in Sunbury, but that future came sooner than expected when running back Nolan Buirley, and quarterback Eli Stumpf among several others stepped into starting roles and turned in all-conference seasons. Nine underclassmen can be found on first and second teams for 2024, a testament to just how deep the program is right now.
From one OCC to another, Ashland’s program was everywhere in the Ohio Cardinal Conference awards. Junior quarterback Nathan Bernhard won Offensive Player of the Year with over 2,000 passing yards and 39 total touchdowns this season. Tyler Sauder, Carson O’Brien, and head coach Scott Valentine are also award winners in the conference. Big Walnut has seen some tough offenses this season with teams such as Bishop Watterson, Westerville North, and Westland, but there hasn’t been an offense ran by a quarterback of Bernhard’s caliber on the Eagles’ schedule so far this season. On the other hand, none of Ashland opponents present the same challenges that Big Walnut can bring. It’ll be interesting to see how both teams respond tonight.
Division III, Region 11
#4 Licking Valley (11-1) vs. #1 Bishop Watterson (12-0)
Bishop Watterson
Second Round: #8 Jackson 34-0
Licking Valley
Second Round: #5 Bloom-Carroll 29-17
Fantastic 50 prediction: Bishop Watterson -20
At this point of the season, it becomes a lot harder to find matchups in which we’ve seen both teams outside of Division I. Bishop Watterson and Licking Valley check that box Region 11. Licking Valley features Central District Defensive Player of the Year, defensive back Kam Walker who doubles as a threat in the passing game, and Quinn Hornfeck, another lengthy DB who can make plays on the ball. The Panthers will also rely on their senior running back Trenton Markus to set the tone on offense. Licking Valley won 9 regular season games, including a signature win over Granville that won them the LCL title for 2024. Their only loss came in week two, when West Muskingum beat them in overtime.
Bishop Watterson has been a buzzsaw to everyone on their schedule. They’ve shut down Division I teams, blown through other premiere Division III opponents, and demoralized their CCL rivals. The range of athletics from players like Drew Bellisari, Cal Mangini, Ben and Jake Uhlenhake, Zack Weber and really just about anyone else in Bishop Watterson’s rotation of players makes them two-dimensional and one of the deepest teams in the state of Ohio. We are still waiting to see if or when someone will present a challenge to the Eagles in this region. With each passing week, that answer continues to look like it will be a ‘no’.
Division IV, Region 14
#3 Ontario (11-1) vs. #2 Shelby (12-0)
Shelby
Second Round: #10 Ottawa-Glandorf 26-14
Ontario
Second Round: #6 Clyde 38-7
Fantastic 50 prediction: Shelby -4
For over a year, we’ve seen the greatness of Shelby quarterback Brayden DeVito through social media, and a few weeks ago, we finally saw it in-person as well. DeVito’s seven touchdown performance stamped himself in Mr. Football conversations—if he wasn’t there already. His efforts brought the outright MOAC title back to Shelby after a 50-36 shootout win over Ontario n week nine. Quarterback and future Ohio State wide receiver Bodpegn Miller had his own sensational performance, doing everything he could on the ground, in the air, in the secondary, and even on special teams to try to will Ontario to a win that night, but it wasn’t enough. The Warriors will get another crack at their MOAC rivals tonight, with so much more on the line in the postseason. While many are unsure of what either team presents as a challenge to the favorite in this region (Perkins), another great semifinal should be in store on this side of the bracket.
Division V, Region 19
#4 Harvest Prep (9-2) vs. #1 Ironton (11-1)
Harvest Prep
Second Round: #5 Columbus Academy 48-7
Ironton
Second Round: #8 Portsmouth 44-0
Fantastic 50 prediction: Ironton -20
History repeats itself in Region 19. For the second year in a row, we get a highly anticipated Harvest Prep-Ironton matchup in the regional semifinals. Just like last year, Ironton enters the game as heavy favorites. Harvest Prep never found another win that stacked up to their first one over Pickerington Central, a win that sent shockwaves through Columbus. Otherwise they would’ve earned themselves a higher seed. Last season, the Warriors used a rushing attack and key stops on defense to knock off the Ironton 20-14. This season they’ll look to do the same, but now have the added wrinkle of a passing threat in Collin Boff, and an even more polished Jamarcus Jones (Central District Defensive Player of the Year) at cornerback and receiver, who will be looking to make a game changing impact once again.
The gap between Ironton and the rest of Southern Ohio continues to be astonishing. The Fightin’ Tigers are consistently beating 8, 9, and 10 win teams by 40 points in that region. Their rivals Portsmouth got outscored 94-0 in a three-week span. Portsmouth was an 8-win team in Division V this year. Division III Jackson was dragged 51-14 by Ironton earlier this season, and 10-win Fairland was blanked 41-0. Still alive in this region is 14-seed Wheelersburg—another team that Ironton beat by 30. Harvest Prep is the last legitimate threat to Ironton until at least the state semifinals. They have one of the most dangerous players in Ohio High School football in Shaun Terry, who should be in high consideration for Mr. Football, and have plenty of athletes in the secondary, headlined with Penn State commit Joshua Johnson.